Friday, April 18, 2008

Please leave if [vol. 7]: Death Cab for Cutie

Plans by Death Cab for CutieThe rational behind these posts is you can't like everything. Taste is a funny thing. Even the most tolerant among us can't stand anchovies, or have a fear of rollercoasters, or don't like French movies. Plus, I never made any claims of being tolerant (in fact, I'm pretty anti-tolerance, for reasons that you might not expect... ask me about it!).

Serioulsy though, wouldn't it be nice if there were little stickers on every food, CD, board game, TV show that you thought about trying out which told you whether you were going to like it or not. Why isn't everyone doing this?!

It makes me sad to write this post though because today I'm going to have to exclude a group of artists that I really like, but whose worldview is simply incompatible with my own. I saw this band when they came and played in Santa Barbara December 2007. They put on a fun show and write unbelievable songs.

So, it is with humility and sorrow that I have to ask Death Cab for Cutie and all they're fans, to please leave.

No, don't say anything. You'll only make it worse. Please, just go. Just go.

*Slow, self-conscious steps. A glance back. Door closing softly.*

Wow. That was harder than I thought it was going to be. Now that we're alone I can talk freely about why I had to do that.

It all comes down to the song "I'll Follow You into the Dark."

The first verse reads:

Love of mine
Someday you will die
But I'll be close behind
I'll follow you into the dark
No blinding lights
Or tunnels to gates of white
Just our hands clasped so tight
Waiting for the hint of the spark
I know, it's a beautiful song, and yes, it describes a love that is committed and pure and wonderful. I wish I had someone to love like that.

However, I don't believe death is like that. I don't know Ben's spiritual beliefs, but to me this smacks of atheism.

It's the chorus that disturbs me most:

If heaven and hell decide that they both are satisfied
Illuminate the "no"s on their vacancy signs
Heaven and Hell ARE NOT hotels with very different waitstaff! Maybe he was just looking for a good rhyme, but it's a silly thing to suggest.



Here's the thing, you don't have to be a Christian to enjoy my music or like reading this blog, but if you're a hardcore atheist then I don't think we'll get along very well. I'm just trying to make it easier for you.

PS I'd love to be proved wrong though.